Yesterday was Black Monday in the NFL. As the NFL Network sat round table discussing the firings of some head coaches the conversation turned naturally to the hiring of some new head coaches. Over time the conversation morphed into the state of minority hiring at the key NFL franchise management positions of General Manager and Head Coach.
On the four man (no women) desk were host Steve Wyche, analyst Marc Ross, former GM and contributor Charley Casserly and a fourth whose name we couldn’t discern. Time and again the refrain was that the NFL needed to do a better job of identifying, training, and interviewing potential minority candidates. Time and again the refrain was that too few African Americans occupied these important positions. Ross stated that only 3 or 4 head coaches were black. It was flat out stated and repeated that the NFL needed to do a better job in creating diversity in the workplace.
Casserly once participated on the committee that created the Rooney Rule. Adopted in 2003, the Rooney Rule is a National Football League policy that requires league teams to interview ethnic-minority candidates for head coaching and senior football operation jobs. It is sometimes cited as an example of affirmative action, as there is no quota or preference given to minorities in the hiring of candidates. Yesterday he expanded on it’s intent and the progress that has been made. The panel listened and was unimpressed.
Yesterday’s news in and out of the NFL as well as their well intentioned discussion made us wonder.
One, in the ultra competitive NFL would owners choose GM’s and coaches based on race? Or is it always about qualifications and perceived future success? Either you win or you walk.
Two, how many black coaches or GM’s would make the NFL “truly diverse?” Would it be a percentage equal to the population in the U.S.? That percentage is somewhere less than 15% per the last census. If so 15% of 32 teams would mean 5 black head coaches. If you have 3 or 4 pending comings and goings right now are you that far off? Or, to be diverse, should it be more?
Three, so does it mean more than that? The data collected by The Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport (TIDES), shows that 70% of NFL players were African Americans at the start of the 2018 season. Should 70% of the GM’s and head coaches be black?
Four, what about other minorities, or women, being included in this diversity shortcoming. Nearly 52% of America is female. Shouldn’t 52% of the above mentioned positions go to females? NBA Commissioner Adam Silver, in his state of the league address last year said, “there is no reason why 50% of our coaches shouldn’t be women.” Apparently the NBA is progressive. The NFL is not.
Once upon a time all NFL place kickers were “straight on” kickers. Hell, they even employed the disabled. One kicker only had half of a foot. Now 100% are “soccer style” kickers. It seems like the league is predisposed, dare we say prejudiced, to one type of kicker. That isn’t very diverse. Ah, but the difference in the kicking style is the “how,” not the “who” you say. In other words anyone can kick as long as they are successful and are “sidewinders.”
Maybe anyone can man the running back position too as long as they are successful? Sure. Christian McCaffery, the only white running back of note in the entire league, has had such a great season that he might be a top MVP vote getter this year. See. Diversity indeed.
U Haul, the trucking company, announced yesterday that they were going to a “no nicotine” hiring policy beginning in 2020 and beyond. So much for diversity. If you can kick the habit come work for us.
The NFL says if you can kick a football come work for us. But, it’s time to stop kicking this can down the road when it comes to hiring head coaches. The NFL needs more diversity in certain positions of employ. In others it’s doing just fine. No need to take a knee after all.
Noted academicians, scholars, constitutionalists, and deep thinkers ranging from Michael Moore to Alyssa Milano weighed in. Even “Meathead” himself Rob Reiner got even with the old, prejudiced Archie Bunker. They all did a Twitter dance or two filled with glee. One even called the President a MF.
when the former Cornhusker player took the reins as it’s head coach in early 2018. Nebraska finished 4-8 in 2018. It just finished a 5-7 campaign this year that included a 2-4 record v Big 10 West Division foes, and 3-6 against the Big 10 in all. Their wins came against South Alabama, Northern Illinois, Illinois, Northwestern and Maryland. The better teams on their schedule scored early and often v the leaky D. The best teams like Ohio St., Minnesota, and Wisconsin beat them by 41,27, and 16 respectively proving that the road to success is still in the distance.