Ed Note: This article was originally published Monday. An email out glitch prevented the subscribers from knowing that until Tuesday. Sorry.
BBR attempts each time it puts virtual pen to virtual paper to deliver a story that has an interest to a diverse national readership.
Coach Ed Orgeron of the Fighting Tigers of LSU was hardly that when he took over a proud football program that was stuck in neutral due to a stubborn coach named Les Miles. Three years later a storybook15-0 season and an NCAA Championship made him just that. Throw in some folksy “down on the bayou” logic and a big dose of the biggest frog anyone has ever had in his throat and you have a human interest story as well.
So how did this rags to riches story turn back to rags just 20 months later? One of our staffers is quite close to the program and shares his thoughts this AM.
- In the SEC winning is the only thing. A 9-8 record since the 15 and 0 run highlighted by a listless performance at Kentucky a week ago is reason number one. When you make $9 million a year you don’t go 9-8. When you coach in the SEC and make “only,” say, $4.5 million you don’t go 9-8 and survive either.
- Winning cures everything. Losing exposes everything. Orgeron’s actions while in front of the team, representing the team, and in his personal life away from the team had enough yellow flags in the last 20 months that they collectively went from a concern to a strong reason number two for his departure.
- O has never been a coordinator on either side of the ball. Therefore, he needed to surround himself with two good ones. He ran through OC’s like Auburn ran through his rush defense. It went from Ensminger to Canada (who he had a fistfight with four games into his tenure) to Ensminger/Brady to Lineham to Peetz in five years. That’s five coordinators, two buyouts, and too many losses in too short of a timeframe.
- He also gave then DC Dave Aranda, now a successful head coach at Baylor, a nudge out of the door late in the great 2019 season. Ed wanted more pressure, more four-man fronts. He said so publicly. Out goes Aranda, in comes a three-year guaranteed contract for Bo Pelini. LSU’s defense in 2020 was historically its worst EVER statistically speaking. Pelini was bought out after one year.
- What were they? One was when he failed to dodge a question posed by a Fox News anchor in an interview about football life with the covid problem in 2020. With little time remaining on-air she pivoted and asked what O thought of then-President Trump. Instead of separating himself and the team from politics he warmly embraced Trump. “President Trump is doing a great job.” O is entitled to his opinion, but he needed to keep it to himself as the leader of the team. It divided the team and the school’s leadership that he spoke out. Free speech is no longer free.
- Two, the numerous off-field dalliances of a newly single man should have been private but were too public in today’s video and social media world. It’s his private life until it’s not. The optic caused concern for a school with way too many Title IX transgressions.
- Three, he had one too many “new friends” attending practice with or without their children running around like they, not LSU, owned the place. It was a minor distraction or three that added fuel to the brush fire. It showed a lack of focus on the job at hand when the hand that feeds him had just jumped his contract from four to nine million a year and guaranteed the next four years.
- He had one too many brush-ups with fans or foes. The second to last was calling out an overserved UCLA supporter and challenging him to a fight pregame. “Bring your ass on in your sissy blue shirt,” Orgeron said. The Tigers had little fight during the game losing 38-27 against a perceived inferior opponent in game one of this year that needed marked improvement from a 5-5 prior year. The last was taking a question on his weekly radio show from a prankster who Oregeron then told that he “would find a fishing hole for.” Individually harmless enough, collectively a sore spot.
- What’s next for O? He’s going to finish out the year as HC for the Tigers then move on. So, Orgeron is the interim coach replacing Orgeron until year’s end. Odd? Maybe somewhat. Then, we’ll see. His days as a head coach are done. Maybe a friend like Lane Kiffin could hire him as a defensive line coach which would be a back to the future move for both. Or, his personality could fit well on local radio assuming anyone could understand him over the air. Or, he could take his $17 million dollars that LSU will buy him out with over the next 18 months and sail away with his companion of choice.
- What’s next for LSU? What is overlooked by recency bias is that LSU has been on a two decades-long run. 2019 was the best of the years, but 2003 and 2007 ended with LSU hoisting the most important trophy of all. In 2011, they finished runner-up. It’s a top ten job in America. An argument could be made that it’s top 5. The AD has a chance to do what O ultimately failed to do-hire a great person, trust them to do their jobs, and keep your nose at least clean enough.
Let the name game speculation begin.